GitLab vs. GitHub: Which is Better [2024]

Introduction

In software development, efficient version control systems are indispensable. Among the top contenders in this domain are GitHub and GitLab, two platforms that have revolutionized how developers collaborate, manage projects, and maintain code integrity. As of 2024, the debate between GitLab vs GitHub is more relevant than ever, with both platforms offering various features tailored to the evolving needs of developers. This detailed guide will delve into the nuances of each platform, compare their offerings, and help you decide which one is the best fit for your development projects.

What is Git: A Quick Overview

Git is a fast, open-source version control system that tracks changes in computer files and manages software development projects of all sizes. Highly popular among software developers, Git offers collaborative work without interference. Linus Torvalds created Git in 2005 for the Linux kernel.

Each time a change is made to the code, a snapshot of the entire codebase, which can also include non-code items, is taken. This allows developers to easily review or revert to previous versions of the code, thereby improving code quality and standards.

Git stands out from traditional version control systems (VCS) by allowing you to work swiftly on various branches of the software product simultaneously.

Git is essential for teams that focus on feature-based development. You can manually grant access to other developers over a LAN. 

Understanding the basics of GitLab vs GitHub

GitHub

GitHub is a cloud-based platform that provides hosting for Git repositories, allowing developers to store, manage, and track changes to their code. It is designed to facilitate collaboration, enabling multiple developers to work on projects simultaneously without conflicts. 

GitHub offers various features to enhance the development workflow, including tools for code review and collaboration, such as pull requests and inline comments. It also includes project management features like issue tracking, project boards, and milestones to help teams organize and manage their work effectively.  

Additionally, GitHub Actions provides automation of build, test, and deployment processes through continuous integration and deployment (CI/CD) pipelines. Security is a key focus, with features like automated security checks, vulnerability alerts, and dependency management to ensure the safety of the code. Furthermore, GitHub hosts extensive documentation, user forums, and a marketplace for additional tools and integrations, fostering a vibrant developer community.  

Advantages of GitHub 

Extensive Community and Documentation: GitHub has a large and active community that provides comprehensive documentation and support. 

Wide Range of Integrations: Integrates with numerous third-party tools and services, enhancing workflow efficiency.

GitHub Actions: Offers powerful CI/CD capabilities through GitHub Actions, allowing workflow automation. 

Collaborative Features: Provides robust features for code review, issue tracking, and project management, facilitating seamless team collaboration. 

Free Public Repositories: Allows users to create unlimited public repositories without cost, fostering open-source contributions.

GitLab

GitLab is an open-source platform that also hosts Git repositories, but it distinguishes itself with a strong emphasis on DevOps and a comprehensive suite of tools for the entire software development lifecycle. It integrates seamlessly with built-in CI/CD pipelines, automating the processes of testing, deployment, and delivery directly from GitLab repositories.  

This integration supports a more streamlined and efficient workflow from code creation to production. GitLab’s all-in-one platform includes features for source code management, project planning, and monitoring, which help teams manage their projects more effectively. It also provides robust security features, including code quality checks, vulnerability management, and container scanning, to maintain high standards of code safety.  

With its extensive suite of DevOps tools and focus on continuous integration and deployment, GitLab is designed to support the needs of modern development teams. It offers both cloud-hosted and self-managed options to suit different organizational requirements. 

Advantages of GitLab 

Open-Source License: GitLab is open-source, allowing users to modify and customize the platform to fit their needs. 

Self-Hosting Capabilities: Supports self-hosting on any plan, giving users control over their data and infrastructure. 

Integrated CI/CD: Offers a comprehensive CI/CD lifecycle built into the platform, streamlining the development process. 

Comprehensive DevOps Features: This feature set includes code review, project management, issue tracking, and monitoring, providing an all-in-one DevOps solution. 

Robust Security Features: This product provides advanced security measures, including a security dashboard, vulnerability management, and license compliance.  

Detail Comparison of GitLab vs GitHub 

Here is a detailed breakdown of the features of both GitHub and GitLab:

• GitLab vs GitHub: Repository Management

Both GitHub and GitLab provide excellent repository management capabilities. GitHub’s interface is sleek and intuitive, making it easy for new users to get started. It supports unlimited public repositories and offers various collaboration tools, including forks, pull requests, and code reviews.

GitLab, on the other hand, also offers unlimited repositories but stands out with its native CI/CD integration. This makes GitLab an attractive option for teams looking to streamline their development workflows within a single platform.

• GitLab vs GitHub: Continuous Integration and Continuous Deployment (CI/CD)

GitHub’s introduction of GitHub Actions has significantly improved its CI/CD capabilities. With GitHub Actions, developers can automate their workflows, including testing, building, and deploying code. However, it still requires some setup and configuration.

GitLab’s CI/CD is deeply integrated and more mature. With minimal configuration, GitLab CI/CD can automatically detect your project’s language and run tests and deployments accordingly. For teams seeking an out-of-the-box CI/CD solution, GitLab is often the preferred choice.

• GitLab vs GitHub: Project Management

Project management is another area where GitHub and GitLab differ significantly. GitHub offers basic project management tools, such as issue tracking and project boards. It also integrates well with third-party project management tools like Trello and Jira.

GitLab excels in this domain with comprehensive project management features built into the platform. GitLab’s boards, milestones, and roadmaps provide a complete solution for managing projects, making it ideal for teams looking to centralize their development and project management activities.

• GitLab vs GitHub: Security and Compliance

Security is paramount in modern software development, and both GitHub and GitLab offer robust security features. GitHub provides tools like Dependabot for dependency management, secret scanning, and advanced auditing capabilities. 

GitLab takes security a step further with its security dashboard, container scanning, dependency scanning, and vulnerability management. These built-in security features make GitLab a strong contender for organizations with stringent security and compliance requirements. 

• GitLab vs GitHub Community and Support

GitHub’s vibrant community is one of its strongest assets. With millions of repositories and contributors, GitHub provides an unparalleled ecosystem for collaboration and open-source development. GitHub’s support and documentation are extensive, ensuring developers can find help when needed. 

While not as vast as GitHub, GitLab boasts a strong and growing community. Its open-core model encourages community contributions, and its documentation is thorough and continually updated. GitLab also offers comprehensive support plans, making it a viable option for enterprise environments. 

Similarities Between GitLab and GitHub

Here are the common features of both platforms to give you a clearer understanding of their capabilities and basics.

Parameter	GitHub and GitLab
Third-party integration services	Both come with numerous third-party integrations.
Issues setup	Milestones, assignees, and issue statuses can be quickly set up on both platforms.
Issue tracking	Both have issue-tracking features that help assign members to resolve issues and update their status on-demand.
Clear labeling scheme	Both employ a clean labelling scheme to streamline software development monitoring.
CI/CD services	CI/CD services are available on GitHub via third-party apps, while GitLab has pre-configured CI/CD services.
Self-hosted	Both offer self-hosted versions, though GitHub provides enterprise plans.
Wiki-based documentation	Both provide extensive wiki-based documentation.
Preview code changes	Previewing code changes is possible on both platforms.
Multiple issue assignees	GitHub offers a public repository on a free plan, whereas GitLab has paid plans for this feature.
Team discussions	Both platforms support team discussions.
Project management dashboards	Both support project management dashboards.
Load performance testing	GitHub offers load performance testing features within the app, while GitLab provides this with paid plans.

Difference between GitHub vs GitLab

Parameter	GitLab	GitHub
Minimum hardware requirement	4 vCPUs and 4 GB RAM, support up to 500 users.	4 vCPUs, 32 GB RAM, 150 GB attached storage, 200 GB root storage, supports up to 20 light users.
Configuration is done by	Editing the GitLab configuration file and executing reconfiguration.	Using the GitHub admin web interface and saving changes.
Requires a dedicated backup host	No	Yes
Allows horizontal scaling	Yes	No
Has true HA (High Availability)	Yes	No
Open source	Yes	No
Allows users to make public repositories	Yes	No
Allows users to have unlimited free repositories	No	Yes
Provides the feature of navigation into repositories	Yes	No. GitHub permits users to navigate usability.
Has project development charts feature	Yes	No
Security	More secure	Less secure
Includes a Security Dashboard	Yes	No
Includes License Compliance	Yes	No
Owned by	GitLab Inc.	Microsoft Corporation
Advantage	A highly secure, cloud-native application that is freely available.	Helps create organized documentation for the project and share work publicly.
Disadvantage	Contains many bugs, leading to a poor user experience.	Limited private repositories and supports only Git version control.

GitHub vs GitLab vs Bitbucket 

Bitbucket, owned by Atlassian, is deeply integrated with other Atlassian products like Jira and Confluence, making it a strong choice for teams already using these tools. 

Key Features of Bitbucket 

• Unlimited Private Repositories

One of Bitbucket’s standout features is its provision of unlimited private repositories, even on its free plan. This is particularly advantageous for small teams, startups, and individual developers who need private spaces for their code without incurring additional costs. Unlike some platforms that impose limits on the number of private repositories or charge for this privilege, Bitbucket’s policy encourages users to adopt the platform without financial barriers. 

• Built-in CI/CD with Bitbucket Pipelines

Bitbucket Pipelines is Bitbucket’s integrated continuous integration and continuous deployment (CI/CD) service. This feature allows developers to automate their build, test, and deployment processes directly within Bitbucket. With Bitbucket Pipelines, you can define your CI/CD configurations using a simple YAML file, making it easy to set up and maintain.

Project Management Integration 

Bitbucket seamlessly integrates with Jira, Atlassian’s popular project management tool. This integration provides a cohesive experience for teams that use Jira to track issues, manage sprints, and plan releases. The integration allows for automatic linking of Bitbucket commits, branches, and pull requests to Jira issues, providing complete visibility into the development lifecycle from within Jira. 

Code Review 

Bitbucket offers robust code review features that enhance collaboration and code quality. Pull requests are central to this process, enabling team members to make changes, review code, and discuss improvements before merging changes into the main codebase. Inline comments and suggestions facilitate detailed code reviews, allowing reviewers to pinpoint specific lines of code for feedback. 

While Bitbucket is a robust platform, it often needs to catch up to GitHub and GitLab in terms of user experience and ecosystem. However, for teams entrenched in the Atlassian ecosystem, Bitbucket remains a strong contender. 

Choosing the Right Platform in 2024 

Choosing between GitHub and GitLab in 2024 depends on your specific needs, team size, and project requirements. Here are some considerations to help you decide: 

When to Choose GitHub 

Open Source Projects: GitHub’s vast community and visibility make it ideal for open-source projects. 

Ease of Use: GitHub’s user-friendly interface is perfect for teams new to version control. 

Integration Ecosystem: If you rely heavily on third-party integrations, GitHub’s extensive ecosystem is beneficial. 

Community Support: The large and active GitHub community provides abundant resources and support. 

When to Choose GitLab

All-in-One Solution: For teams looking for an all-in-one DevOps platform, GitLab’s comprehensive features are unmatched. 

Built-in CI/CD: If integrated CI/CD is a priority, GitLab’s native pipelines simplify the process.

Project Management: GitLab’s robust project management tools are ideal for teams wanting to centralize their workflow. 

Security and Compliance: GitLab’s advanced security features make it suitable for organizations with strict security requirements.

The choice between GitHub and GitLab in 2024 should depend on your project’s specific needs and priorities. You can consider the strengths of each platform and how they align with your team’s workflow and goals. Both platforms offer powerful tools to enhance your development process, so the right choice will depend on which features are most important to your project’s success.

Leverage Your Web Project With Artoon Solutions

Artoon Solutions is committed to leveraging the strengths of various platforms to deliver exceptional ReactJS Web Development services, ensuring that our clients receive the best possible solutions tailored to their unique requirements. By carefully evaluating your workflow, security needs, and integration preferences, you can make an informed decision that enhances your development process and drives success in 2024 and beyond!

Call us at +91-832-0329-068 to book your free consultation today, and let’s discuss your web project requirements! 

FAQs 

1. GitHub vs GitLab – What are the differences in minimum hardware requirements?

The minimum hardware requirements for GitHub are 32 GB RAM, four vCPUs, 150 GB attached storage, and 200 GB root storage, supporting up to 20 light users. For GitLab, the minimum requirement is four vCPUs and 4 GB RAM, supporting up to 500 users. 

2. Is there any difference between Git and GitLab?

Git and GitLab are both widely used in software development but serve different functions. Git is a version control system that tracks changes in code over time, while GitLab is a web-based Git repository manager that offers a comprehensive DevOps platform for team collaboration. 

3. Is there any difference between Git and GitHub?

Yes, Git is a version control system. GitHub is a web-based platform that hosts Git repositories and offers collaboration tools. 

4. GitHub vs GitLab – Which one is the best?

If you prefer a large developer community and an intuitive interface, GitHub might be the better choice. However, if you seek more control over your infrastructure and need a built-in CI/CD system, GitLab could be more suitable. 

5. Is GitLab more secure than GitHub?

Both platforms implement strong security measures to protect user data and prevent unauthorized access. However, GitLab provides unique security features such as static application security testing (SAST), pre-configured CI/CD pipelines, container scanning, and dynamic application security testing (DAST). 

6. GitLab vs GitHub – How do they differ in terms of disadvantages?

GitHub is limited to private repositories and supports only Git version control. At the same time, GitLab has several bugs that can negatively impact the user experience.